Sue’s Hat,
2013
(Click on
images to see larger)
We all know the tired bromides about
giving:
“tis better to give than receive.”
“It’s a joy to give.”
“Blessed are those who can give.”
“We make a living by what we get. We make a life by what we
give.”
But
let’s be honest. It’s always more fun to receive than give, especially if the
gift is unexpected and something that you really value.
On
Saturday I was reminded how getting can be giving. Or was it how giving can be
getting. Whatever.
I
was down at the oceanfront looking for people to photograph. The annual
Boardwalk Art Show was in session. There were stylish culture vultures and
clueless tourists alike strolling the oceanfront boardwalk.
I
hadn’t been there long when I noticed a woman wearing an interesting hat. I
told myself I had to photograph the hat and the woman wearing it. But she kept
ducking into the various artists’ stalls where the light was bad and I felt
like I’d be intruding if I were to ask her for a chance to photograph her hat.
Eventually
she stepped out and agreed to let me photograph her. She was even flattered and, as
we say here in the American South, “tickled” that someone had shown interest in
her hat. It turns out the hat has a long story. It had been passed among
friends and relatives across several generations, with each new owner adding something to it, and actually has intersections with people
and places in my life.
When
we were done the woman asked if I’d send her a copy of the picture. It was only
when I introduced myself and asked for her name and address that it became
embarrassingly clear that this woman was Sue, someone I’d known briefly about
twenty-five years ago. We hadn’t even recognized each other. But we had a fond
reunion all because of the hat. Sue’s so happy she’ll have a picture with all
the other women who have owned it.
A
few minutes later I was photographing some red glass art against the background
of the blue ocean. The glassblower asked
if I wouldn’t mind taking a picture of her booth for her to use in future art
show applications. She was tickled, too, that I could do something for her.
Finally,
a little further down the boardwalk I happened to notice a lovely woman wearing
a shimmering green dress with white polka dots on it. I walked past her several
times before concluding that I needed to photograph her, too. It turns out she’s a
semi-professional singer who knew of my late mother, who was also a singer. Ms. E was also
tickled—I swear she used that very word--that I’d admired her dress and asked
to photograph her.
So
although I didn’t think of these encounters as transactions, the joy of giving to these three ladies was far
greater than the value of the three photographs I got. That I could surprise at least two of them with these small
gifts was a joy.
Ms. E in Green,
2013
I can imagine Martin Parr taking these pictures - but for different reasons, and treating the subjects and photographs differently than you did. (Have I told you how much I *detest* Martin Parr? Probably only 50 or 60 times...) One of the great things about these pictures is how much of your friendly interaction with the people is apparent - even in the picture of the hat where Sue's head is turned.
ReplyDeleteI was tickled to read this. ;-)
ReplyDeleteI know it's "tired" as you say, but yes, sometimes the evidence that giving really IS better, and IS joyful, becomes apparent to us in ways we didn't expect or plan.